Skip to main content
Back

Rutgers Study Reframes Why Older Immigrants Deliberately Avoid Apps

A qualitative CSCW study reframes older Korean immigrants' digital avoidance as strategic refusal, not skill deficits, with implications for inclusive design.

Pro

Paper, Full Access
  • Rutgers researchers reframe older Korean immigrants' digital non-use as strategic refusal, not skill deficits.
  • Study introduces pragmatic disengagement and interdependent navigation as new frameworks for CSCW.
  • Based on 22 semi-structured interviews using community-based participatory research in the greater NYC area.
  • Participants use KakaoTalk and YouTube heavily but strategically avoid online banking and political content.
  • Design recommendations include full-stack language support, dignity-preserving collaboration features, and emotion-sensitive curation.
  • No code or dataset released; qualitative HCI research contributing conceptual framework and design principles.

A new study out of Rutgers pushes back on one of the most persistent assumptions in digital inclusion research: that when older immigrants avoid apps, ignore features, or hand their phones to their kids, it means they can't keep up. The paper, headed to CSCW, argues these behaviors are deliberate, culturally grounded strategies for staying safe, dignified, and connected in digital environments that were not designed with them in mind.

Authors Jeongone Seo and Tawfiq Ammari spent time with 22 older Korean immigrants across the greater New York City metro area, and their central move is a conceptual one. They identify pragmatic disengagement, where users selectively reject emotionally taxing or linguistically risky technologies, and interdependent navigation, where digital literacy operates as a distributed, relational resource rather than an individual skill. In plain terms, opting out is often a choice, and competence often lives in the family group chat rather than any single person.

Why the skill-deficit framing breaks down

Most digital divide interventions treat the gap as a training problem. Give someone a tutorial, a translated interface, or a bigger font, and adoption follows. The paper argues this misses what actually happens on the ground.

Consider the layers of uncertainty an older immigrant faces when a new app pops up an English prompt. There's technical uncertainty (what does this button do), linguistic uncertainty (I can't parse the error message), relational uncertainty (do I really want to ask my daughter again), and epistemic uncertainty (is this content even true). When these stack, the rational move is often to close the app. The study documents this across daily interactions with KakaoTalk, YouTube, and emerging AI tools.