Skip to main content
Back

Copenhagen Researchers Say Search Engines Are Killing Ethical Shopping

A SIGIR perspectives paper argues that search engines are systematically failing shoppers who want to buy ethically, and outlines what IR needs to fix.

Pro

Paper, Full Access
  • SIGIR '25 perspectives paper argues search engines are a major reason ethical shopping intentions fail to translate into purchases.
  • Survey of 601 consumers: 73% of even highly ethical shoppers did not search for ethical aspects on a recent $100+ purchase.
  • Top blockers reported: hard to find info, too time consuming, assumed prior knowledge was sufficient.
  • Proposes three reframings: information extraction, complex search task, and knowledge calibration.
  • Highlights GreenDB, OpenFoodFacts, and LLM-based extraction as promising building blocks.
  • Full paper: arxiv.org/abs/2604.10751.

Most shoppers say they want their purchases to reflect their values on sustainability, labor rights, or animal welfare. Almost none of them actually shop that way. A new perspectives paper from researchers at the University of Copenhagen, Strathclyde, and Aalborg University pins a surprising amount of the blame on information retrieval systems themselves, and lays out a research agenda for fixing them.

The paper, From Query to Conscience, was presented at SIGIR '25 in Padua. It combines a survey of 601 consumers with a literature review to argue that ethical shopping is fundamentally an IR problem rather than a purely moral one.

The gap between good intentions and checkout

The researchers clustered 601 participants by their Ethically Minded Consumer Behavior (EMCB) scores, finding that 29.09% were essentially ethically agnostic, 43.72% were moderately ethically minded, and 27.19% were highly ethical consumers. You would expect the last group to actually search for information about ethics when shopping. They mostly do not.

Even in the high-EMCB cluster, roughly 73% of participants either did not consider or did not search for ethical aspects when making a recent purchase over $100. The intention exists. The behavior does not follow.

When asked why, participants pointed to a consistent set of failures in the search experience: information was too time consuming to find, hard to find at all, or shoppers assumed they already knew what they needed to. Qualitative complaints piled up around not being able to validate claims about rare earth metals in electronics, feeling overwhelmed by choice, or simply not seeing ethical details on product pages.